Alms are what Paul brought unto his nation – Israel – for the poor saints there (Acts 24:17).
Dorcas did almsdeeds by making coats and garments for widows – a good work (Acts 9:36-39).
Jesus was not dealing with a matter of liberty here, but rather teaching how to rightly keep a duty; alms, or charitable giving to the poor, is not a matter of liberty, but a duty of pure religion (Jas 1:27).
Consider the compassion and kindness of God in giving laws to protect and provide for the poor.
Israelite farmers planted into the corners of their square fields, but they harvested them in circles!
Israelites could not incorporate the year of release into their interest calculations on debt service!
Consider the gravity with which these laws were given, God said, “I am the LORD your God.”
Our Lord prefaced His instruction for proper almsgiving with a warning to take heed (Matthew 6:1).
There is a very strong impulse in the depraved hearts of men to be seen and praised for alms.
Due to the greed and pride of human nature, giving to the poor is contradictory and difficult; therefore most men that give do it to be seen of others and get an indirect reward for it.
The Jewish religious leaders and the rich were setting a terrible example with public almsgiving.
The Lord Jesus, teaching common people knowledge, did not want them to miss their reward!
While the truly righteous would give without a reward, the Lord mentions the reward thrice.
There are great rewards for godly almsgiving, which are forfeited by the evil motive of man’s praise.
If alms are given with a goal of being seen of men, then there will be no reward from God in heaven.
The sin that angers God is hypocrisy – pretending great zeal for religion but doing it for praise.
The error is not merely giving your alms in public view, as we shall see clearly (Acts 4:32-37).
The sin here is not doing alms before men, but rather doing them before men to be seen of them!
Giving to the poor for the glory and praise of men is to miss the mark and forfeit God’s reward.
Any effort to let men know about your charity to be thought well of by them is to displease God.
If you design by public acts or slips of the tongue to honor yourself, that is all you get – nothing.
Our Lord used hyperbole regarding your left and right hand to strongly encourage private giving.
Hyperbole is an obvious exaggeration to make a point that readers understand without confusion.
Exaggeration to embellish your accomplishments for vainglorious pride is entirely different.
The Lord had used strong metaphors by suggesting eye-plucking and hand-amputation (5:29-30).
You know, without any confusion or doubt at all, that you cannot literally keep His words here.
The intent, dictated by the context and the rest of Scripture, is to avoid any ostentatious giving.
Intense secrecy in giving is not the point, for God endorsed humble public giving (Acts 4:32-37).
The sinful practice Jesus condemned was giving charity in order to be seen and admired by men.
Giving in secret is only secret as far as men are concerned, for the eyes of the Lord behold it all.
The eyes of the Lord are in every place, beholding the evil and the good (Proverbs 15:3).
His beholding our evil produces fear; His beholding our good produces confidence and joy.
Your heavenly Father sees in secret Himself – He is not dependent on others telling Him of you.
Your heavenly Father will reward you Himself – you do not need the rewards of public honor.
If you give in secret, God will see your secret giving; and He will reward you openly for it.
A man who has his mind and heart set on impressing others is angered to have to give in secret.
The eyes of the Lord run to and fro through the earth to bless such righteous men (II Chr 16:9).
The Text Applied
The text has little meaning for those that do not give; you need to start giving alms even today; pure religion is remembering orphans, widows, and others afflicted souls in their troubles (James 1:27).
God will bless the man that considers the poor, which takes conscious effort and actions (Ps 41:1-3).
God rewards giving to the poor. It is incredible to watch the greedy get poorer and poorer, because they reason they cannot afford to give, because they must keep it for themselves (Pr 11:24-25). Hah!
If you do not have an object for alms now, save your money or give it to the church (I Cor 16:1-2).
You can wait for the poor; God will give opportunity. Be ready in heart and purse (I Tim 6:17-19)!
We do not use offering plates because they are a common way of tempting men to Pharisee giving.
There are two aspects of giving to remember: God loves generosity and cheerfulness (II Cor 9:6-7).
Do not forget the priorities and rules of Christian charity: #1, poor in your family; #2, poor in your church; #3, poor in other churches; #4, poor victims God puts in your path, whether sinner or saint.
A righteous man does not seek the reward greedily; he sincerely cares for the poor and afflicted and obedience to God whether there is a reward attached or not.
The first commandment is loving God, and the second commandment is loving your neighbor as yourself; these two commandments are inseparably tied together (I John 5:1).
The poor can also give, though they may give less; Jesus sees two mites given with the right heart; the poor must guard against an evil and wicked heart (Pr 28:3; Luke 21:1-4).