Psalms Commentary

Psalm 55:21

The words of his mouth were smoother than butter, but war was in his heart: his words were softer than oil, yet were they drawn swords.

Psalm 55:21 describes the dangerous speech of hidden treachery. David is not dealing with an open enemy only, but with the bitter wound of betrayal by men near enough to speak peace while preparing harm (vv.12-14). Historically, this verse most directly captures the flatteries of Absalom, who stood by the way of the gate, lamented the lack of justice, wished himself judge, and kissed those who drew near; “so Absalom stole the hearts of the men of Israel” (2 Samuel 15:2-6). His words were smoother than butter, but his ambition was war against his father and king. The broader setting also includes Ahithophel, David’s trusted counsellor, who joined Absalom’s conspiracy and whose counsel David feared enough to pray, “O LORD, I pray thee, turn the counsel of Ahithophel into foolishness” (2 Samuel 15:31).

“The words of his mouth.” The mouth is named first because the betrayal appeared by speech. The man’s words had sound, shape, and sweetness. He knew how to speak. He knew how to sound safe. He knew how to lower suspicion. But Scripture teaches that words must not be judged by pleasant sound only. “He that hateth dissembleth with his lips, and layeth up deceit within him” (Proverbs 26:24).

“Were smoother than butter.” Butter is soft, pleasant, and easy to receive. Such were this man’s words. They were not rough, open threats. They were smooth. They could pass as friendship, concern, sympathy, honour, loyalty, or peace. Smooth words are dangerous when the heart behind them is false. They do not alarm the hearer at first; they soothe him. They make betrayal easier because they quiet caution.

This is one of the great dangers of evil speech. Hard words may reveal an enemy plainly, but smooth words may hide him. A man may speak gently while planning injury. He may use affection, honour, religious language, concern, or counsel to cover treachery. David had known open enemies, but this wound came through a mouth that could speak smoothly.

“But war was in his heart.” Here the Spirit opens what men could not see. The words were smooth, but the heart held war. This is the great contrast of the verse: mouth and heart. The mouth sounded peaceful; the heart was hostile. The lips suggested safety; the inward man prepared conflict. God sees both. Men hear the words, but the LORD tries the hearts.

This clause perfectly exposes Absalom’s rebellion. His speech at the gate sounded like justice, compassion, and public care, but his heart was set on stealing the kingdom. He did not begin with swords in the street. He began with words, sympathy, kisses, and political flattery. The war was already in his heart before it appeared in open revolt. Thus Psalm 55:21 reveals treason before it is visible to men: smooth words may be the first movements of war.

The clause also teaches that speech is not made righteous by tone. Men often mistake soft speech for good speech. But God does not judge words by softness alone. He judges truth, purpose, heart, and fruit. A lying tongue may speak gently. A flattering mouth may sound kind. A traitor may talk peace while sharpening a sword. Therefore, the righteous must not be simple concerning smooth words.

“His words were softer than oil.” The image is repeated and heightened. Oil soothes, softens, and heals. His words seemed medicinal, gentle, and safe. They may have sounded like counsel meant to help, peace meant to calm, or friendship meant to comfort. But the comparison is bitter because the softness was false. The words felt like oil, but they were not healing.

Oil in Scripture can be connected with honour, gladness, healing, and consecration. Therefore words “softer than oil” may carry a fair appearance. They may seem gracious, careful, spiritual, or wise. Absalom’s fair speeches won men’s hearts. Ahithophel’s counsel had great reputation. But fair appearance cannot sanctify falsehood, treason, or malice. Smoothness is not holiness.

“Yet were they drawn swords.” This is the terrible reality beneath the softness. The words were weapons. They did not look like swords, but they cut like swords. They did not appear drawn, but they were ready for harm. A drawn sword is not an ornament; it is prepared for use. So were this man’s words. They were shaped to wound, divide, betray, and destroy.

Absalom’s words became drawn swords against David because they stole loyalty, gathered sympathy, and prepared rebellion. He did not need to strike David with his own hand to begin the attack. Words can turn hearts before armies move. Speech can prepare war before blood is shed. A soft tongue may be the first weapon in a violent cause.

This is why Psalm 55:21 belongs with the Bible’s strong warnings about the tongue. “There is that speaketh like the piercings of a sword” (Proverbs 12:18). Again, the wicked “whet their tongue like a sword” (Psalm 64:3). Words can pierce names, reputations, peace, friendships, churches, families, and lives. The mouth may be smoother than butter and still be carrying a blade.

The verse also warns against flattery. Flattery is not praise; it is selfish, false, or manipulative speech designed to gain advantage. “A man that flattereth his neighbour spreadeth a net for his feet” (Proverbs 29:5). It may praise another in order to use him, comfort him in order to win him, or agree with him in order to turn him. Such speech is not love. It is a net.

This verse should make every reader examine his own speech. Are words used to help or to maneuver? Are they faithful or calculated? Are they spoken in truth or shaped to win influence? Are they soft because they are gracious, or soft because they hide a sword? It is possible to speak gently and sin greatly. God hates a lying tongue, a false witness that speaketh lies, and him that soweth discord among brethren (Proverbs 6:16-19).

It also teaches the righteous not to trust appearances too quickly. Christian charity does not require foolishness. A soft voice, religious words, and familiar friendship do not prove a true heart. David knew the grief of treachery from those near to him. The prudent man must judge words by truth, fruit, faithfulness, and the fear of God, not by charm.

Yet this verse is not written to make saints bitter or suspicious of every friend. David still prays. He still casts his burden upon the LORD (v.22). He does not let betrayal destroy his faith in God. The answer to smooth treachery is not a hard heart, but deeper trust in Jehovah. Men may speak with hidden swords, but God’s word is pure, faithful, and safe.

Jesus Christ suffered this treachery in its fullest measure. Judas came with words of greeting and a kiss, while his heart delivered the Lord to murderers (Matthew 26:48-50). The chief priests used pious language while seeking false witness. The rulers pretended concern for Caesar while rejecting the King of glory. Yet Christ was not deceived, and He went forward according to the counsel of God. David suffered betrayal by a son and by a counsellor; Christ suffered betrayal by a familiar disciple, false witnesses, envious priests, and unjust rulers, that the scripture might be fulfilled.

Psalm 55:21 therefore exposes the fearful evil of smooth words with a warlike heart. The mouth may be smoother than butter while the heart is full of conflict. Words may be softer than oil while they are drawn swords. Let every tongue fear hypocrisy, flattery, deceit, and speech that harms. Let every betrayed saint carry the grief to God. The LORD knows the difference between soft words and true words, between fair speech and faithful speech, between a gentle voice and a drawn sword.

↑