Psalms Commentary

Psalm 42:5

Why art thou cast down, O my soul? and why art thou disquieted in me? hope thou in God: for I shall yet praise him for the help of his countenance.

Psalm 42:5 is the first great refrain of this psalm. The psalmist has described his soul panting after God as a hart panteth after the water brooks (v.1). His soul thirsts for God, the living God, and he longs to appear before Him (v.2). His tears have been his meat day and night, while enemies ask, “Where is thy God?” (v.3). He remembers former days of worship, when he went with the multitude to the house of God with the voice of joy and praise (v.4). Now he turns inward and speaks to his own soul. He does not let sorrow preach alone. He rebukes, questions, and commands his heart by faith.

“Why art thou cast down, O my soul?” The psalmist addresses his own soul directly. This is holy self-examination. He does not deny his sorrow, but he questions it. To be cast down is to be bowed low, pressed down, and sunk under the weight of grief. His soul is not calm. It is low. Yet he will not allow this low condition to rule without challenge. David often spoke to his own soul this way: “Bless the LORD, O my soul” (Psalm 103:1). Here he says in effect, Soul, why are you lying so low when God is still God?

This question is not the voice of scorn toward weakness. The psalm has already shown real distress. Thirst, tears, absence from the house of God, enemy reproach, and inward heaviness are not imagined troubles (vv.1-4). Scripture does not require saints to pretend they are untouched by grief. Hannah was in bitterness of soul and prayed unto the LORD, weeping sore (1 Samuel 1:10). David himself confessed elsewhere, “I had fainted, unless I had believed to see the goodness of the LORD in the land of the living” (Psalm 27:13). The question in Psalm 42:5 is not, Why do you feel anything? It is, Why are you cast down as if hope were gone?

“O my soul.” The battle is inward. Enemies may speak outside, but disquiet rises within. A man may be outwardly still and inwardly storming. Therefore, the psalmist does not begin by answering his enemies; he first addresses his own soul. This is wise. If the soul is governed by fear, unbelief, memory, or grief, outward answers will not settle it. The heart must be brought back under the rule of faith. “Keep thy heart with all diligence; for out of it are the issues of life” (Proverbs 4:23).

“And why art thou disquieted in me?” Disquiet is inward tumult, agitation, noise, and unrest of spirit. The soul is not only low; it is restless. Thoughts rise and fall. Fears speak loudly. Memories of former worship make present absence feel sharper (v.4). Enemy reproach presses the wound deeper (v.3). This is what affliction often does. It does not always crush a man in silence; sometimes it fills him with inward noise. The psalmist wisely names the condition. He does not let confused feelings remain unnamed and unjudged.

The repeated “why” is important. Faith interrogates sorrow. It asks sorrow for its warrant. It calls the soul to give account before God. This does not mean every grief is sinful. The Lord Jesus Himself was sorrowful and very heavy in Gethsemane (Matthew 26:37-38). But sorrow must not be allowed to become unbelieving rule over the soul. The psalmist asks why his soul is cast down and disquieted because he knows there is a greater truth than his present feeling.

Psalm 131 gives the opposite condition. There David says, “LORD, my heart is not haughty,” and then, “Surely I have behaved and quieted myself, as a child that is weaned of his mother” (Psalm 131:1-2). Psalm 42 shows a soul not yet quieted, but disquieted within him. The remedy is not pride, self-pity, or uncontrolled inward noise, but the same humble discipline: bring the soul low before God, command it to hope in Him, and wait for His help. The cast-down soul must be taught to become the weaned soul.

“Hope thou in God.” Here is the command. The psalmist does not tell his soul to hope in changed circumstances, human sympathy, former experiences, public worship restored at once, or the silencing of enemies. He says, “Hope thou in God.” Biblical hope is confident expectation grounded in God Himself. Men hope in health, money, peace, friends, plans, and earthly stability, but these can fail in an hour. God cannot fail. “Happy is he that hath the God of Jacob for his help, whose hope is in the LORD his God” (Psalm 146:5). “It is good that a man should both hope and quietly wait for the salvation of the LORD” (Lamentations 3:26).

This command also shows that the believer must speak truth to his own heart. The soul does not always make its way upward into hope. It must be commanded there. Feelings must be instructed. Fears must be answered. Memory must be governed. The word of God must be brought to bear upon the inward man. When David was sore afraid in Gath, he declared, “What time I am afraid, I will trust in thee” (Psalm 56:3). Psalm 42:5 is the same spiritual discipline. When cast down, hope in God.

“For I shall yet praise him.” Faith now looks forward. The psalmist is not praising as he desires yet, but he believes he shall. “Yet” is a mighty word in affliction. It confesses that the present condition is not the final word. Tears are now his meat day and night (v.3), but praise shall come. He is absent from the joyful multitude now (v.4), but he shall yet praise God. The prophet Micah spoke with similar faith: “Rejoice not against me, O mine enemy: when I fall, I shall arise; when I sit in darkness, the LORD shall be a light unto me” (Micah 7:8). Faith does not deny the darkness. It denies that darkness will have the last word.

This expectation of future praise is a strong cure for fainting. The soul under pressure often speaks as if present pain will continue forever. Faith answers, I shall yet praise Him. Job said, “though he slay me, yet will I trust in him” (Job 13:15). Jeremiah sat amid great affliction, yet confessed, “The LORD is my portion, saith my soul; therefore will I hope in him” (Lamentations 3:24). The psalmist follows the same path. He pulls his soul forward by the promise of praise not yet enjoyed.

“For the help of his countenance.” The countenance of God speaks of His face, favour, presence, and gracious regard. The psalmist does not want help separated from God. He wants the help that comes from God’s face shining upon him. The priestly blessing asked the LORD to make His face shine upon His people and be gracious unto them, and to lift up His countenance upon them and give them peace (Numbers 6:24-26). David elsewhere prayed, “Make thy face to shine upon thy servant: save me for thy mercies’ sake” (Psalm 31:16). The help of God’s countenance is not bare relief; it is mercy with God’s favour in it.

This is why hope in God is better than hope in deliverance alone. A man may desire escape from sorrow while having little desire for God. But Psalm 42 begins with thirst for God Himself (vv.1-2). Verse 5 keeps that same direction. The help he longs for is the help of God’s countenance. He wants the living God, not a lifeless change in circumstances. If God’s face shines, the soul can praise again. If God withholds His felt favour, no outward comfort can satisfy the thirst described in this psalm.

The verse also teaches the believer how to deal with spiritual heaviness. Do not let a cast-down soul become your teacher. Do not let disquiet write your doctrine. Do not let tears interpret God. Question your soul, command it to hope in God, and set before it the certainty of future praise. The psalmist does not wait for his soul to feel ready. He commands it: “hope thou in God.” The heart often follows truth after truth has first been spoken to it.

Jesus Christ shows the perfect life of hope under sorrow. He was sorrowful and very heavy, yet He prayed to the Father and submitted to His will (Matthew 26:37-39). He endured the cross for the joy set before Him (Hebrews 12:2). He was not ruled by present suffering, but by the Father’s will and the glory beyond it. The afflicted saint learns from Him to carry sorrow to God, submit under God, and hope in God.

Psalm 42:5 is therefore a holy argument against despair. The soul may be cast down, but it must not conclude that God is gone. The soul may be disquieted, but it must not be allowed to govern the man. Hope thou in God. The day of praise is not finished. The face of God is still the help of His people. Let every thirsty, tearful, unsettled believer learn this refrain and use it well: Why art thou cast down, O my soul? Hope thou in God, for thou shalt yet praise Him for the help of His countenance.

↑